It has been several weeks since oil price movements have told us anything significant about changes in fundamentals.That’s what analysts at Standard Chartered Bank, including Commodities Research Head Paul Horsnell, said in a report sent late Tuesday. “A period of price undershooting, exacerbated by a magnetic storm of top-down macroeconomic fears, fed momentum-following algorithms,” the analysts stated in the report.
“This resulted in an extended price fall exacerbated by a final stage of gamma hedging as banks sought to cover the risk from options they had sold to producers,” they added.
“The negative feedback loop seems to have been reinforced by an unusually high degree of groupthink among hedge funds and other speculative flows led by a (usually unquantified) market narrative of a current or impending supply glut,” they continued. “The overwhelming (and surprisingly uniform) bearishness among money managers has taken positioning in crude oil and oil products to the most bearish extreme since the start of the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) in 2008,” the analysts went on to state. In the report, the Standard Chartered Bank representatives said obtaining a clear short-term directional signal from fundamentals is almost impossible in such a dislocated market.
“Extreme positioning, groupthink, and algorithmic trading strategies are still generating far too much noise,” they warned.
“However, we think there will be two key price drivers when dislocations ease.
First, there is no supply glut; indeed September looks like being the tightest month of the year due to seasonal demand strength and supply outages in Libya and the U.S. Gulf,” they added.
“Second, no supply glut is likely in at least Q4-2024 and H1-2025 if OPEC+ producers keep to their commitments. We think the actions of a small group of producers, particularly Iraq, will be the key factor for prices but the market appears some way from focusing on this,” they continued.
In a research note sent t by the JPM Commodities Research team on Tuesday, J.P. Morgan analysts said they believe the market is currently overemphasizing bearish drivers and highlighted that they see today’s global crude markets as tight. “Global crude inventories are below last year’s levels, when Brent was trading at $92, and at 4.42 billion barrels are the lowest on record since Kpler began tracking data in January 2017,” the J.P. Morgan analysts said in the note. “Meanwhile, both OECD crude and liquids inventories sit below their five-year range and five-year averages and oil stocks at Cushing are severely depleted by the standards of the last 15 years,” they added. “It is these draws out of oil inventories that are influencing our pricing model to show that Brent’s fair value today is $82 per barrel, $10 above the spot price,” they continued. The J.P. Morgan analysts said in the research note that they believe the decline in prices “is due to an expected glut in the market in 2025, as reflected in the curve structure, and concerns that OPEC and its allies will hike production into the surplus”. “To calm the market, key coalition members announced on September 5 that they won’t increase production by 180,000 barrels per day in October and November. Yet their longer-term plan to revive 2.2 million barrels per day of idle supplies gradually over the course of 12 months remains in place, with the completion date pushed back two months to December 2025,” they added. “While the announcement stabilized Brent in low $70s, the decision to prolong supply restraint for another two months may only defer rather than resolve the challenge for OPEC to next year,” they warned.
A Rystad Energy oil macro update from Rystad Energy Senior Analyst Svetlana Tretyakova, which was also sent on Tuesday, noted that, despite ongoing concerns over weak demand, global liquids and crude balances are expected to remain tight through the end of 2024, with stock draws anticipated. “On crude, supply is notably constrained, with the year over year change in crude and condensate supply expected to turn negative for the first time since 2020,” the update stated. “Global crude oil supply is expected to decline by 220,000 barrels per day year on year in 2024, primarily due to extended OPEC+ cuts, reduced Libyan output, and weaker performance from non-OPEC+ producers,” it added. “OPEC+ members, including Saudi Arabia and Russia, are maintaining voluntary cuts of 2.2 million barrels per day until November 2024, with the potential for further extensions. U.S. oil supply growth has been revised down to 280,000 barrels per day, reflecting a decline in Bakken output and modest Permian growth,” it continued. “Libyan production has dropped sharply due to political disruptions, while Brazil’s output is projected to recover in the second half of the year, and Nigeria’s production outlook is improving with steady growth,” it noted. “Additionally, our preliminary estimate indicates Hurricane Francine might result in a 1.8-million-barrel production loss in the Gulf of Mexico over two and a half days,” the update went on to state.


